Dick wrote this text in the early 1960's, but it seems we are rapidly approaching a time where we can nearly produce the simulated memories Rekall provides. What are some ethical dangers associated with memory erasure/implantation? Would you go to rekall?
What are the dangers that can happen with a memory implantation?.. Well in this case it brought up memories that Douglas was suppose to forget. In reality: I believe it can cause some type of traumatic stress on the brain and also cause other memory lost. If anything they should find a way instead of it being memory implantation, it should be a way to take out certain memories for people with Alzhmimer's, so if and when they start to forget things they have either a visual image or the same process as Rekall. Would I use Rekall? No: why would I just want a fake memory of me doing something I never did, I would much rather do something physically, so I can have that sense of accomplishment. An implantation seems to be too easy.
ReplyDeleteGreat thinking, Alzehimers which is forgetting, is a good contrast to this fake implanted memory.
DeleteDouglas Quail, the main character, opens the story with his far fetched desire to leave earth and travel to Mars, a dream his wife belittles him for and tries to discourage him from even thinking about. He goes off to work but instead of going there he travels to an appointment to take a "recall" course. Rekal, Inc. is a business which can implant mind memories in your brain so you think the memories are real even though you never experienced them for real. Doug would go to Mars in his mind for much cheaper than a real trip and fully believe he had gone there.
ReplyDeleteGood summary, but look more at the question, would you go to Rekal?
DeleteCan you retype the question please because i could not find it. I read it and I summarized it. I would definitively not go there. It Sounds way too out of the ordinary to me.
ReplyDeleteThe question is right above this box, in the post. The newest post first on the top of the screen
ReplyDeleteDick wrote this text in the early 1960's, but it seems we are rapidly approaching a time where we can nearly produce the simulated memories Rekall provides. What are some ethical dangers associated with memory erasure/implantation? Would you go to rekall?
What are some ethical dangers associated with memory erasure/implantation? Would you go to rekall?
ReplyDeleteI have done some reach and I found out that there was a movie based on that story "Total Recall" It sounds like a dangerous stage. I personally would not do it. In the story implanting memories did not seem to be working out very well. Based on my personal experience , I have struggle with my memories too but I would never have a memories implant. This is way too technology based. I would rather natural way of getting back my memory.
Rekal could be the only option for someone to grant their wishes. Dick illustrates this through Quail: while Rekal is an artificial surrogate, it is also a fulfillment of long-lasting desire. Rekal could offer individuals a chance to become happier and more complete. For example, if I futilely dream about climbing Mount Everest, then Rekal looks like a better option than struggling over my dream until my deathbed.
ReplyDeleteThe problem is the integrity of the implanted memory. Will we receive the exact desired memory? Or will the procedure erase a priceless memory fragment? This leads to another issue: the morality of our desires. If a person wants to insert memories of fulfilling social taboos via Rekal, the implications and repercussions are endless.
In reality, things could be more complicated. Any intervention in the human psyche may have unexpected and dangerous results. We grow through our personal experiences; we build our memories and judge them through a prism of our morals and values. As people, we are permanently in a process of adjustment. A new piece of implemented memory combined with the erasure of any fragment may produce contradictory results, possibly causing harm or changing the individual completely. Any intrusion may have startling drastic consequences.
Concerning the Mount Everest matter, I will probably suppress my desire or find a substitute rather than using Rekal. It sounds depressing; let me think it over again.
ok ethics is really the study of morality - how we determine what is right or wrong - these things have changed in society as time passed - for example we (USA) used to have legalized slaves which today is considered unethical (wrong) so who determines what the injected morality would be? it could be used by immoral people to create soulless assasins (like in the story) - it could be used to block important memories or even religious beliefs - on the other hand it could be used to block terrible memories of awful things that may have happened to someone freeing them from stress and depression in their future and giving them a better chance at success in surmounting tragic events. i would not want to go to ReKal because i do not trust them to do the right thing... if i could feel comfortable with it i also wouldn't know what memories i would replace or implanted although implanted would be more interesting in the long run - think of the pleasurable memories that could be implanted!
ReplyDeleteEthical dangers associating with memory implantation is risking a chance of destroying proper functions of the brain. After getting the procedure done, you may begin to experience delusions and begin to hallucinate as a side effect. Anything can go wrong with memory implantation! For example, when Quai Douglas was getting his implantation, there were technical difficulties and McClaine was called in to analyze a situation .
ReplyDeleteAs for memory erasure, there just might be some benefits to that! Memory erasure would probably be ideal for someone who has been physically or emotionally affected by an experience which caused them to have a rough life. Whether it was a terrifying experience like; being bullied, a abusive (physical or verbal) relationship with someone, or a very embarrassing moment that they want to forget which lowered their confidence / self esteem and kept them from moving forward in life. Memory erasure would be ideal for them because in a sense, it would be as if they’re “born again”. Their minds would be rejuvenated and negative thoughts would not exist. The memory erasure will give them a “nothing can stop me” attitude because they won't remember who said they couldn't do something positive and they won't remember things that made them depressed and kept them from progressing.
I WOULD NOT go to Rekall ! Although it might sound a little tempting, but going to rekall is making a huge decision, even Douglas had his doubts until McClaine convinced him to go along with the procedure, and Douglas being the gullible man that he is , desperately wanting to bring his dream to life, went along with the Rekall procedure. The company is also very unprofessional! At times you have to read the fine print and see beyond a fantasy and think about the aftermath because, that fantasy that one yearn for can turn out to be a Nightmare.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI have serious mixed feelings about memory erasure/ implantation. I guess it all depends on if it is my chose or some higher power deciding what I should and shouldn’t know. I wouldn’t want anyone having that kind of dominance over my life, which is my biggest fear. It’s too similar to slavery for me, in fact it is slavery cause let’s be honest, if you control the mind of a creature you control that creature. Its horrifying the think of what can happen of government could alter our memories.
ReplyDeleteBut I might consider going to Rekall incorporated if I knew it was a hundred percent safe and a hundred percent my chose. There are millions of things that are just not possible for us to do; like seeing the world in its entirety or even other worlds as shown in the text. Most of us can’t afford traveling to a different state far less a country or planet. Some of us have physical disabilities that limit what we can do. So to have an option/ opportunity to fulfill a dream by implanting the experience is a blessing. It would also be great to forget traumatic moments in your life, like maybe some form of assault or anything that is emotionally intolerable. A lot of us hold on to pain that we wish we didn’t have to. Would it be so bad to be able to clean your slate and have a happier life? wouldn’t we all want that?
Some excellent thoughts here, I would ask anyone who has not yet posted, rather then start a new thread please respond and comment on anothers ideas, not only thinking critically about their statement, but adding your own thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI think we can all agree that memory implantation or memory erasure is a foreign concept in which no human has experienced yet. Furthermore anyone from dentist to heart surgeons are liable to mistakes, now imagine someone messing with our memories , how many things can go wrong when people are probing at your brain ? As a result it can cause complete memory loss or make you believe that you live an entirely different life. In fact for some people that might be necessarily a bad thing. i suppose that it wouldn't be the worst thing if i were able to forget my worst memories, but then again my memories are what makes me who i am. Would i go to Rekall? Honestly it would be a question based on my health. For example if i were terminally sick or disabled in some way i would absolutely want to experience memories i would no have experienced otherwise. However if i was healthy just on the risk of the side effects i would not risk it although it would be tempting.
ReplyDeleteOnce again I'm intrigued by your choice of question. The concept of transhumanism this is a question of morality. I do believe that with technology advancing exponentially every year humans will try and incorporate technology in what it means to be human in the foreseeable. This will have a large trail and error phase like Joseph said doctors do make mistakes and to be willing to risk irreversibly damaging your brain in order to add some sort of technology will initially be a huge risk. However as our understanding of technology and the human body expands the probability of failure over time will dwindle. As long as there are those with money seeking a way to remain isolated and better from the remainder of society there will be a market for such things and research will be easily funded. Much like all other technology when it is new it is only accessible for those who can afford it.
ReplyDeleteI said this was a question of morality because it really depends on an individual's belief. There are no limitations to technology. If someone were to create a server that could hold an infinite amount of memory information its hard to say i would not join. It depends on what is publicized. Society today is very trendy i do think it depends on the media's advertisement because the media ultimately has the most influence on people. Now in this generation possibly more influence than heritage and culture. All due to technological growth. Personally i don't think i would be interested in rekall. I think it takes away from what it means to be human.
foreseeable future*
DeleteRegardless of race, sex, or financial status, most people dream of doing something more grand and with more impact when compared to the events of their past. Essentially, Rekal would attract customers from all sides of the spectrum. As If we don't have enough crazies in nyc, imagine getting into a subway cart where the man to your left believes he has superhuman strength, and the woman across from you is under the impression that just a week ago she saved the world from an alien invasion. Imagine a president who believes that by cutting taxes for the rich, the money saved will eventually "trickle down" to the less fortunate and create jobs even though statistics show that ever since the wealthy started getting tax cuts unemployment has gone up. Well that's the kind of world we'd live in with rekal. Though the idea of rekal sounds inviting and fun, it's hard to imagine believing you did something without any consequences. No matter how realistic the experience, once you go back to the real world, all the flaws, inconsistencies, and randomness can start to aggravate you and drag you back to rekal in search of the perfect life. At this point, and assuming you have the money for it, you spend most of your life hooked up to a machine feeding false memories into your head like a crack addict who just wants to get a little bit higher. So no, I'd rather just try to make my fantasies a reality in real life, and if I fail to do so, it will only reassure me that I'm human.
ReplyDelete